Pirates Cove Pizza & Subs Menu (Update 2025)

Welcome to Pirates Cove Pizza & Subs, a hidden gem located at 126 E Main St, Cardington, OH. This lively eatery offers a tantalizing menu that is sure to delight your taste buds. Every pizza is crafted with fresh, quality ingredients—each slice bursting with flavor, whether you prefer classic pepperoni or adventurous specialty pies.

Not just pizzas, their subs are a must-try, filled with premium meats and fresh veggies. Each bite transports you to flavor paradise, making them the perfect pairing with a hearty side of garlic knots.

Conveniently, Pirates Cove accepts credit cards, ensuring a smooth dining experience. For those looking for a quick meal or a hangout spot with friends, this friendly establishment checks all the boxes. Their commitment to quality and flavor makes dining here an unforgettable experience.

Call (419) 864-5766 for takeout or visit today to embark on your culinary adventure!

8 Subs

8 Captain Hook Sub

Ham, salami, mushroom, onion, green mild pepper, sauce, cheese.

$7.00

8 Buccaneer Sub

Ham, salami, sauce, cheese.

$7.00

8 Italian Sub

Ham, salami, onion, cheese, lettuce, tomato, side of Italian.

$7.00

8 Meatball Sub

Meatballs, sauce, cheese.

$7.00

8 Pizza Sub

Pepperoni, sauce, cheese.

$7.00

8 BLT Sub

Bacon, lettuce, tomato, side of mayo.

$7.00

8 Ham Cheese Sub

Ham, cheese.

$6.50

8 Veggie Sub

Mushroom, onion, green mild pepper, sauce, cheese.

$6.50

8 Steak Sub

Steak, onion, green pepper, cheese, side of mayo.

$7.00

8 Buffalo Chicken Sub

Hot sauce covered chicken, lettuce, tomato, side of ranch or blue cheese.

$7.00

8 Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub

Chicken, bacon, mozzarella cheddar, lettuce, tomato, side of ranch.

$8.00

8 Chicken Parm Sub

Chicken, sauce, cheese.

$7.00

12 Captain Hook Sub

Ham, salami, mushroom, onion, green mild pepper, sauce, cheese.

$8.50

12 Buccaneer Sub

Ham, salami, sauce, cheese.

$7.75

12 Italian Sub

Ham, salami, onion, cheese, lettuce, tomato, side of Italian.

$8.50

12 Meatball Sub

Meatballs, sauce, cheese.

$8.50

12 Pizza Sub

Pepperoni, sauce, cheese.

$8.50

12 BLT Sub

Bacon, lettuce, tomato, side of mayo.

$8.50

12 Ham Cheese Sub

Ham, cheese.

$7.75

12 Veggie Sub

Mushroom, onion, green mild pepper, sauce, cheese.

$7.75

12 Steak Sub

Steak, onion, green pepper, cheese, side of mayo.

$8.50

12 Buffalo Chicken Sub

$8.50

12 Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub

Chicken, bacon, mozzarella cheddar, lettuce, tomato, side of ranch.

$9.50

12 Chicken Parm Sub

Chicken, sauce, cheese.

$8.50

12 Subs

Italian Dressing

$0.50

Ranch Dressing

$0.50

French Dressing

$0.50

Honey Mustard

$0.50

1000 Island Dressing

$0.50

Blue Cheese Dressing

$0.50

Raspberry Vinaigrette Dressing

$0.50

Pizza Sauce

$0.50

Garlic Butter Sauce Cup

$0.50

Alfredo Sauce

$2.00

Beer Cheese

$1.25

Buffalo Sauce

$1.00

Garlic Parmesan Sauce

$1.00

Smokey BBQ Sauce

$1.00

Golden BBQ Sauce

$1.00

Hot Honey Sauce Cup

$1.00

Taco Sauce Packet 2

$0.50

Sour Cream Packet 2

$0.50

Mayo Packet 2

$0.50

Icing

$1.50

Pirates Cove Pizza & Subs Menu (Update 2025)

Build Your Own

Individual 7

SMALL 10

MEDIUM 12

LARGE 14

X LARGE 17

SHEET 18X26

SMALL 10 Deluxe Pizza

SMALL 10 Extreme Meat Pizza

SMALL 10 Taco Pizza

SMALL 10 Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

SMALL 10 Veggie Pizza

SMALL 10 Cheezy Garlic Pizza

SMALL 10 Chicken Alfredo PIzza

SMALL Specialty Pizzas

MEDIUM Specialty Pizzas

MED 12 Deluxe Pizza

MED 12 Extreme Meat Pizza

MED 12 Taco Pizza

MED 12 Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

MED 12 Veggie Pizza

MED 12 Cheezy Garlic Pizza

MED 12 Chicken Alfredo Pizza

LARGE 14 Deluxe Pizza

LARGE 14 Extreme Meat Pizza

LARGE 14 Taco Pizza

LARGE 14 Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

LARGE 14 Veggie Pizza

LARGE 14 Cheezy Garlic Pizza

LARGE 14 Chicken Alfredo Pizza

LARGE Specialty Pizzas

XLARGE Specialty Pizzas

XL 17 Deluxe Pizza

XL 17 Extreme Meat Pizza

XL 17 Taco Pizza

XL 17 Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

XL 17 Veggie Pizza

XL 17 Cheezy Garlic Pizza

XL 17 Chicken Alfredo Pizza

SHEET Deluxe Pizza

SHEET Extreme Meat Pizza

SHEET Taco Pizza

SHEET Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

SHEET Veggie Pizza

SHEET Cheezy Garlic Pizza

SHEET Chicken Alfredo Pizza

SHEET Specialty Pizzas

8 Subs

8 Captain Hook Sub

8 Buccaneer Sub

8 Italian Sub

8 Meatball Sub

8 Pizza Sub

8 BLT Sub

8 Ham Cheese Sub

8 Veggie Sub

8 Steak Sub

8 Buffalo Chicken Sub

8 Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub

8 Chicken Parm Sub

12 Captain Hook Sub

12 Buccaneer Sub

12 Italian Sub

12 Meatball Sub

12 Pizza Sub

12 BLT Sub

12 Ham Cheese Sub

12 Veggie Sub

12 Steak Sub

12 Buffalo Chicken Sub

12 Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub

12 Chicken Parm Sub

12 Subs

SUB BOWL

Captain Hook Bowl

Buccaneer Bowl

Italian Bowl

Meatball Bowl

Pizza Bowl